Tender Response Examples: Good vs Bad Answers and Editable Template

See a weak and a strong tender response to the same question, with annotations, a comparison table and a reusable Word template for your own bid.

Published: 4 November 2026 · 9 min read

Topic: Tender Writing

Most tender advice tells you to be clear, specific and evidence-led. It rarely shows you what that looks like on the page. This guide does. You will see one fictional tender question, a weak answer, a strong answer and a side-by-side comparison. You will also get a reusable template.

Everything in the examples is fictional, including the buyer, the contract, the scoring and every company claim. Please do not copy them into a live bid. If you are still getting to grips with the paperwork, start with our tender documents guide.

What Does a Good Tender Response Look Like?

A good tender response makes it easy for an evaluator to give you marks. Buyers publish their award criteria and how they will assess them, so your job is to answer exactly what is asked. Under the Procurement Act 2023, which applies to new procurements from 24 February 2025, contracts are awarded to the "most advantageous tender", not simply the cheapest. Government guidance also says criteria should be clear, measurable and specific, so vague answers are hard to score.

Here is a simple six-part anatomy of a strong answer:

  1. Answer: respond directly to the exact question, in the order asked, using the buyer's own terms.
  2. Method: explain how the work will be done, step by step, not just what you promise.
  3. People: name who is responsible, by role at least.
  4. Controls: describe the checks, audits, reports and escalation routes that keep delivery on track.
  5. Proof: give measurable evidence such as figures, dates, sites and outcomes.
  6. Coverage: answer every published criterion and sub-question, including the ones that feel minor.

If one of these is missing, ask whether the evaluator can still find the marks.

Example Tender Question and Scoring Criteria

Important: this procurement is fictional. Eastmere District Council does not exist, and the scoring below is an illustration, not a forecast of how any real buyer would mark.

Buyer context (fictional): Eastmere District Council wants an integrated facilities management provider for its Civic Centre and Library complex. The site is open to the public six days a week and includes council offices, a library, a meeting hall and a small café.

Service scope (fictional): planned preventive maintenance, reactive repairs with a helpdesk, statutory compliance testing and records, and minor works. The contract runs for three years, with an option to extend for two more.

Assumptions (made visible):

  • The Council supplies an asset register of about 600 items.
  • TUPE may apply. Real bidders must check this in the actual documents.
  • The Council wants mobilisation completed within eight weeks.
  • Each criterion is scored 0 to 5, then weighted.

Question 3 (fictional): "Describe how you will deliver the facilities management service at the Civic Centre and Library complex. Your answer must cover: (a) staffing and supervision; (b) your mobilisation plan for the first eight weeks; (c) your methodology for planned and reactive maintenance; (d) how you will monitor quality and performance; and (e) how you will escalate and resolve service failures."

Word limit: 500 words.

CriterionWeighting
Staffing and supervision20%
Mobilisation20%
Delivery methodology30%
Quality monitoring15%
Escalation and resolution15%

Illustrative rubric (fictional):

  • 0: No response or irrelevant information.
  • 1: Very limited. General statements, no detail or evidence.
  • 2: Partial. Some detail but gaps, or unsupported claims.
  • 3: Acceptable. Addresses the requirement with reasonable detail and some evidence.
  • 4: Good. Clear, specific, well controlled and evidenced.
  • 5: Excellent. Every part is covered, with detailed methods, named responsibilities, strong controls and measurable proof.

Weak Tender Response Example

Below is a complete weak answer to Question 3. The square-bracket labels are not part of the answer. They show what is going wrong.

We are a leading facilities management provider with many years of experience. [UNSUPPORTED CLAIM: no years, sites or figures] We have a dedicated and highly skilled team who are passionate about excellent service. [VAGUE PROMISE AND OVERLOOKED (a): no headcount, roles, qualifications or supervision] We will maintain the Civic Centre to the highest standard. [VAGUE PROMISE: "highest standard" is not defined or measured]

We will mobilise quickly and smoothly so there is no disruption. [OVERLOOKED (b): no timeline, stages or Council involvement]

Our approach to maintenance is proactive and flexible. We will carry out planned maintenance and fix problems as they arise. [MISSING METHOD (c): no schedule, standards, priorities or response times]

We are committed to continuous improvement and will regularly check our performance. [MISSING CONTROLS (d): what is checked, how often, by whom, against what target?]

If there are any problems, we will deal with them promptly. [OVERLOOKED (e): no escalation steps, timings or named roles]

We have excellent customer feedback and a strong track record. [UNSUPPORTED CLAIM: no client, score or date]

In plain terms: phrases like "highest standard" and "promptly" cannot be scored because nobody can check them. There are no controls, no evidence, and sub-questions (a), (b) and (e) are barely answered. Under the illustrative rubric, an evaluator would struggle to justify more than a 1 or 2. That is a teaching point, not a prediction.

Strong Tender Response Example with Annotations

This is a complete improved answer to the same question. It is roughly 400 words, inside the 500-word limit, once the square-bracket tags are removed. All names, sites and figures are fictional.

Our service is led by a named Contract Manager, accountable for delivery from day one.

(a) Staffing and supervision. We will deploy a site team of eight: Contract Manager, Site Supervisor, four multi-skilled technicians, one mechanical engineer and one helpdesk coordinator. [STAFFING: headcount and roles] Two technicians hold 18th Edition qualifications and two are Gas Safe registered. The Supervisor is on site 07:00 to 16:00, Monday to Friday, and signs off daily tasks. An out-of-hours engineer is on call every day. All staff hold enhanced DBS checks. Two relief technicians are inducted before go-live to cover absence. [STAFFING: supervision, vetting and cover]

(b) Mobilisation. We will mobilise over eight weeks. [MOBILISATION: timeline] Weeks 1 and 2: staff transfer review where applicable, access set-up and asset register check. Weeks 3 and 4: site survey, compliance gap check and system set-up. Weeks 5 and 6: inductions, safety briefings and helpdesk testing. Week 7: shadowing the outgoing provider. Week 8: readiness review with the Council Contract Officer and go-live sign-off. A weekly report and risk log goes to the Council throughout. [MOBILISATION: stages, sign-off, reporting]

(c) Methodology. Planned maintenance is scheduled in our CAFM system from the Council's asset register and aligned to SFG20. [METHODOLOGY: scheduling and standard] Statutory checks for fire alarms, emergency lighting, electrical, gas and water hygiene sit on a compliance register the Contract Manager reviews weekly. The helpdesk logs and prioritises faults: P1 emergency, on site within 2 hours and made safe within 4; P2 urgent, on site within 24 hours; P3 routine, within 5 working days. Every job closes with photo evidence and a supervisor check. [METHODOLOGY: priorities and response times]

(d) Quality monitoring. We report monthly against five KPIs: planned maintenance completion (98%), P1 attendance within 2 hours (100%), P2 attendance within 24 hours (95%), first-time fix (85%) and user satisfaction (4.5 out of 5 minimum). [QUALITY MONITORING: targets] The Supervisor audits 10% of completed jobs weekly and our Quality Manager audits quarterly. Results are reviewed with the Council monthly.

(e) Escalation. A missed P1 is reported to the Contract Manager within 30 minutes and to the Council Contract Officer within one hour. We give a written root cause within 24 hours and a corrective plan within five working days. If a KPI is missed two months running, our Operations Director joins a recovery meeting and an improvement plan is agreed. [ESCALATION: steps, timings, named roles]

Proof. At Ashbourne Leisure Centre (fictional client, 2023 to date), we mobilised in seven weeks, achieved 99% planned maintenance completion and 92% first-time fix in year one, and scored 4.7 out of 5 for user satisfaction. [PROOF POINT: site, dates, measurable results]

Why the annotations matter: each tag marks a place where an evaluator can find marks. In a real bid, the proof point must be a real contract with figures you can show.

Why One Tender Answer Is Stronger Than the Other

This table shows where marks are likely to be won or lost. It does not predict how a real buyer would score your bid.

Evaluation requirementWeakness in the first responseSpecific improvement in the second response
Staffing and supervision (20%)No headcount, roles, qualifications or coverEight named roles, supervision hours, qualifications, vetting, out-of-hours cover and relief staff
Mobilisation (20%)"Quickly and smoothly" with no planEight-week staged plan with Council sign-off and weekly reporting
Delivery methodology (30%)"Proactive and flexible" with no methodAsset-register scheduling, SFG20 alignment, compliance register, priority levels and response times
Quality monitoring (15%)"Regularly check" performanceFive KPIs with targets, weekly and quarterly audits, monthly reviews
Escalation and resolution (15%)"Deal with problems promptly"Timed steps, named roles, root cause deadline and recovery process
Evidence"Excellent feedback" with no sourceNamed example with dates and measurable results
Full response to sub-questionsSkips or barely covers (a), (b) and (e)Answers (a) to (e) in order, using the buyer's labels

How to Adapt a Tender Response Example to Your Own Business

An example is a shape to follow, not content to copy. Replace each part below with something true about your business:

  • Policies and standards: only name certifications and standards you actually hold or comply with.
  • Staffing: use your real team structure, headcount, qualifications and supervision pattern for this contract.
  • Experience: use real contracts, clients (with permission), dates and outcomes.
  • Site details: take asset counts, opening hours and layout from the buyer's documents.
  • Measurements: use targets and results you can evidence from your own reports.
  • TUPE: check the buyer's documents and take advice. Government TUPE guidance is a useful starting point.

Warning: never paste invented capabilities into a live bid. Made-up figures, case studies or promises you cannot meet can cost you marks and may lead to disqualification or misrepresentation claims later. If you cannot evidence a statement, remove it or find the evidence first.

Quick check before you submit:

  • Does every claim have a source you can point to?
  • Can the named roles actually be provided?
  • Is every sub-question answered, within the word limit?
  • Has someone other than the writer reviewed it?

For the wider process, see How to Fill a Tender Document in the UK: Step-by-Step Guide and Checklist, Bid Writing for UK Tenders: Step-by-Step Guide with Scored Examples, If you are new to bidding, the government's guidance for suppliers and the Find a Tender service are worth bookmarking too.

Downloadable Tender Response Template

The template is an editable Word table you can reuse for every question in a tender. It comes in two versions: a blank copy and a worked example using the fictional Eastmere question.

Blank tender response template (.docx)

Worked example, Eastmere Question 3 (.docx)

What each field is for:

  • Question: paste the exact question, including all sub-questions.
  • Criterion: note the published criterion and weighting so you can see where the marks are.
  • Response: write your answer in the same order as the question, within the word limit.
  • Evidence reference: record where each claim comes from, such as a policy, contract record or KPI report.
  • Owner: name the person who writes and confirms the answer.
  • Review check: tick once someone else has checked accuracy, completeness and compliance.
  • Word count: record the count against the limit.

Blank copy:

QuestionCriterion and weightingResponseEvidence referenceOwnerReview checkWord count
/ limit

Worked example (fictional):

FieldEntry
QuestionQ3: Describe how you will deliver the service, covering (a) to (e)
CriterionStaffing 20%, Mobilisation 20%, Methodology 30%, Quality monitoring 15%, Escalation 15%
ResponseSee the strong example above
Evidence referenceHR-01 staffing plan, OPS-04 mobilisation plan, CASE-02 KPI report, QA-07 escalation procedure (all fictional)
OwnerBid Manager, with Operations Director confirming content
Review checkAll five sub-questions covered; figures checked against sources; second reviewer signed off
Word countAbout 400 / 500

Prepare an Evidence-Backed Tender Response with SupplierVerse

A strong tender response rests on real evidence, clear ownership and a careful read of the question. Supplierverse can help you prepare an evidence-backed tender response, from understanding the criteria to organising your proof points before you write.

All examples in this article, including Eastmere District Council, Ashbourne Leisure Centre, the scoring rubric and every figure, are fictional and for illustration only.

Back to Resources